Article

What is an easement and how can it affect the value of a property in Costa Rica?

An easement — servidumbre in Spanish — is the right to use someone else’s property. If you’re looking to buy property in Costa Rica, you need to know if there are any easements associated with it, and to consider how they will affect the property value.

Difficulties with easements

In one case our office was asked to list a small building lot for sale with a registered easement for a primary power line. The owners had bought the lot without knowing this right of way existed. Nobody had told them about it, not even their own attorney.

All our real estate agents are obliged to run a title check before listing a property, which is how we found out that ICE, the Costa Rican Electricity Institute, had registered the easement but never used it. The easement covered the entire lot, and getting a construction permit would have been impossible. In fact, a luxury condominium – Cerro Alto in Escazú – is right next door and the easement must have run right through that development too.

Long story short, it took us over a year to clear up the title and cancel the easement. Then it took us a week to sell the lot.

Ivo Banner Go Dutch

 

When to find out

There are several types of easements, some that are in the property owner’s favor and some that aren’t. There is a good chance you won’t find out about an easement until after you have bought a property. By then, it is too late to do anything about it. Such an easement can definitely affect the value of a property.

How do you know an easement exists?

Easements are registered in the National Registry on the property title, under “gravamenes y afectaciones.” They are also marked on the survey map. When a property is sold or transferred, the easement transfers with the property to the new owner, unless it is cancelled before transfer. The original easements of access that belonged to the original property before it was subdivided usually will never disappear from the title.

The description of the easement can be found under “citas” in the title description. This information cannot be found online; you have to go in person to the National Registry to check and identify it. Public easements in Costa Rica, except for the ones constituted by RECOPE, the National Oil Refinery, do not have a time limit — they are “forever.”

Here’s a look at various types of easements.

The right to cross

A servidumbre de paso is the right to cross. When a property is subdivided, it might be necessary to create access to those properties that don’t have public road access. The name used can also be servidumbre agrícola, which is used for larger tracts of land and gives an easement to move cattle from one place to another. This is also used for the roads in low-density agricultural communities. You will find many communities like that in Atenas and coastal areas.

161026EasementMap2

Utilities

Utility companies usually create an easement if they have to go across someone’s property with a power line, a water line or a sewage line (public sewage exists in very few places in Costa Rica).

Some of the major utilities in Costa Rica are ICE (power and phone service), CNFL (power), ESPH (water, power and sewage), EM Cartago (power, water, sewage and central market), Jasec (power), AyA (water) and RECOPE (petroleum).

A) Water

A servidumbre de agua is the right to take a water pipe across someone else’s property. In some cases this water easement can be a community’s water holding tank or water well. In some communities, the water pipe for some reason does not run under the road (which could be an exclusive right of way in itself) but runs over all the private properties in the community.

This community water reserve tank is registered as an easement.

This community water reserve tank is registered as an easement.

In some communities, rain water pipes are constituted as an easement. Where there is public sewer, the sewer pipes will be registered as an easement.

Water irrigation canals in agricultural areas are also registered as a water easement.

B) Power

A servidumbre eléctrica or power easement can be for two things:

• Primary or secondary power lines.

• High-tension primary power lines. All activity is prohibited on easements created for high-tension power lines, such as construction, agriculture or moving earth. Nor can you build fences or walls in or on an easement.

C) Phone

One day we might not need any telephone lines anymore, but until then, a phone line can be an easement. Most phone lines are located inside the power easement and not constituted separately.

161026EasementMap1

View

It is possible for a property owner to register a view easement or servidumbre de vista on the neighboring property, as long as both properties belong to the same owner. For that reason, you will only find properties with a view easement in condominiums and master-planned subdivisions. (Theoretically a really nice neighbor could “give” a view easement to the neighbor behind him, ensuring that he won’t block his view.)

View easements are very difficult to describe. Most attorneys who register a view easement describe it in such a way that the neighbor who could take the view away is allowed only a one-story home, or some other maximum construction height is imposed.

Ecological

I have seen a few ecological easements in communities to protect nature and wildlife. They are constituted so that no one will disturb the nature inside the ecological easement. They are supposedly set up to allow animals to pass through that easement. Rarely do animals pay attention to the law in Costa Rica.

How to cancel an easement

To cancel an easement in the property section of the National Registry, you need the cooperation of the person or public entity in whose favor that privilege of use exists. Cancellation of an easement can be by mutual agreement, expiration of its time limit, or change of the property size by the union of two or more properties.

It’s best to let your attorney handle this. If you try to do it yourself, they’ll send you from one place to the other and back and string you along until you decide to just let it go.

Disclosure?

There is no obligation under Costa Rican law to disclose the existence of an easement. Many real estate agents don’t even know how to run a title check and have no knowledge about easements due to lack of training. A buyer depends entirely on the closing attorney, who might or might not find it necessary to disclose an easement.

Before you make an offer on a property, request a title study from your real estate agent and check for existing easements yourself. Then you can ask your lawyer to check and specify the existing easements before finalizing your offer.

Value calculation

It is quite difficult to calculate the value of an easement. The tax department of the Finance Ministry has elaborated a formula to calculate the damage that is used by ICE, AyA and court-appointed appraisers.

Property value

Easements rarely affect the property value, but a public utility easement might. Most buyers do not like high-tension power lines, as some think they can affect your health. Some buyers will simply NOT purchase a property that is close to these power lines.

Some easements might constitute a security risk to a property because they allow access to the public road.

Some easements might actually add value to a property, if they create more green space between neighboring properties.

Every case is different, so look before you leap. If you are considering buying property in Costa Rica, find out if any easements exist, understand what they allow, and consider carefully how they will affect the property value. If you have any doubts, consult a lawyer before you purchase.

Ivo Henfling founded the American-European Real Estate Group in 1999 — the first functioning MLS in Costa Rica with affiliate agents from coast to coast. You can read other articles like this on his blog. Contact Ivo at (506) 2289-5125 / 8834-4515 or at ivo@american-european.net.

16 Comments »

    Thomas Rosenberger | October 27, 2016

  1. Thanks for the useful information and clearly your clients have the best real estate representatives available in this country.

  2. Ivo Henfling | October 27, 2016

  3. thanks Thomas, for your good words. I’m sure you’ve had to deal with easements on your home inspections too. Especially when they’re water tanks or irrigation canals.

  4. Christina Truitt | October 27, 2016

  5. Great article – keep it up

  6. Ivo Henfling | October 27, 2016

  7. Thanks Christina, I appreciate your comment

  8. Al | October 27, 2016

  9. Ivo,well done.

    Al.

  10. Ivo Henfling | October 27, 2016

  11. Thanks for your comment Al.

  12. Douglas Benn | October 27, 2016

  13. Dear Ivo,

    Good article. I am in dispute with my neighbors who claim that the servedumbre is a private road to their house and I cannot access my property beside the water tank from the road to my land. I am getting a lawyer to have a look at this.

    Best wishes.

    Douglas

  14. Ivo Henfling | October 27, 2016

  15. Thanks for your comment Douglas. I don’t have your survey anymore after 12 years, but in the register, it shows the easement is on your land.
    SERVIDUMBRE SIRVIENTE
    CITAS: 323-14331-01-0900-001
    FINCA REFERENCIA 2329098 000
    AFECTA A LA FINCA: 2-00073053
    CANCELACIONES PARCIALES: SI HAY
    ANOTACIONES DEL GRAVAMEN: NO HAY
    It is pretty easy for your attorney to check the “citas” in the register where it will explain exactly what the easement is all about.
    If my memory is not fading, you are giving them access over your property and not the other way around. The easement is on your land. Ask your lawyer to check, the proof is all there.

  16. Paul Meacham | October 27, 2016

  17. Very informative. Thanks!

  18. Ned | October 30, 2016

  19. Wow, Ivo. Always good, relevant and meaningful. Always a pura vida “10” from this retired professor. Good work. You ARE aware, you know, that at the End, this will all become a Book? Right? With Appreciation… ~ Ned

  20. Ivo Henfling | October 30, 2016

  21. Thanks for your 10 Ned. But that’s also with the help of a real good Tico Times editor: Karl Kahler. The book? Maybe when I can find some time, one day.

  22. Walt Zielke | October 31, 2016

  23. Ivo, Nice article and thanks. I have a question or 2 though that you may be able to answer. I have an easement on my land for an ICE electrical tower and for agricultura. Does ICE pay the owners for use of the land through easement? I am certain that there is no payment to the owner for the agricultura but unsure on the ICE use of my land. Thanks.

  24. Ivo Henfling | October 31, 2016

  25. Thanks Walt. ICE pays rent for cell phone towers but not for a high tension primary power lines. The original owner of the farm, was compensated by ICE for life before it was subdivided and you bought a part of it. In any event, check with your lawyer. Yes, you are right about the easement for the farmer. Any payments where made between owners when the easement was constituted.

  26. Brian Schaller | November 23, 2016

  27. I receive a conflict notice when trying to respond to Open House article?

  28. Julian Bakker | December 20, 2016

  29. The observations by Mr Henfling on environmental easements are not fully correct. Such easements do not in the first place serve to let animals pass. Environmental easements often impose on the owner of the land the obligation to conserve existing nature areas of the land, prohibit him to cut trees and only allow to build in a given percentage of the total area. The easements can also prohibit to sub-divide the land. Costa Rica’s Foresty Law of 1996 contains additional provisions to be observed, e.g. protection areas along streams, etc. EALA http://www.latinambiente.org

  30. Ivo Henfling | December 20, 2016

  31. Thanks for your correction Julian!

Leave a comment

  • Article

    Will you get a great deal on a bank-owned home in Costa Rica?

    Is buying a bank-owned home in Costa Rica a good way to find a bargain? Sure, it can be, but it’s hard work. Often, you will see a TV ad with a famous soccer player asking you to purchase a bank-owned home with incredible financing options. It’s just like any other advertising: check before you […]

  • Article

    8 signs you are not ready to buy a house in Costa Rica

    It is quite normal that we encounter a would-be buyer who is not ready to buy a house yet. We advertise our property listings on a few local websites, dedicated to the Tico market. All our agents speak fluent Spanish, so that is not a problem. We often see that a local client is looking […]

  • Article

    Are traffic jams changing the Central Valley real estate market?

    How much is traffic in the Central Valley affecting real estate sales? A change in the market may be imminent as more families try to relocate to a better location closer to their workplace.