News Briefs

Nicaragua’s President Accuses Costa Rica of Trying to Steal Río San Juan

Posted: Tuesday, November 02, 2010 - By Tim Rogers
Nicaraguan President Daniel Ortega claims Costa Rica has expansionist plans and wants to steal the San Juan River, just as it took Guanacaste and Nicoya from Nicaragua 185 years ago.
rio san juan update
Tim Rogers

River of Contention: The San Juan River is again in the middle of heated border conflict between Nicaragua and Costa Rica

Accusing Costa Rica, a country without an army, of “bellicosely threatening Nicaragua ” with “elite troops” dressed like “Rambo,” President Daniel Ortega said his government plans to appeal the border dispute over the San Juan River back to the International Court of Justice at The Hague.

Ortega’s comments, made Tuesday night at his compound in Managua, came in response to Costa Rica’s appeal Tuesday morning to the Organization of American States (OAS) to intervene in the case of Nicaragua’s dredging of the San Juan River – an operation that Costa Rica claims has intruded into its territory.

The situation has become heated in the past few days, leading to a virtual standoff between the Nicaraguan Army and Costa Rican police – both of which accuse the other of being on their territory.

Ortega claims Costa Rica is pretending to be confused about where the real border lays in an attempt to mask its “expansionist” intentions of appropriating the river, as he claims Costa Rica did 185 years ago to the northern Pacific regions of Guanacaste and Nicoya, which used to belong to Nicaragua.

The Nicaraguan president said Costa Rica has “been resistant” to demarcating the border along the San Juan River with landmarks, because this would “end their hope” of someday stealing the river from Nicaragua.

“Who has any doubt that it’s part of the geopolitical vision of Costa Rica to claim ownership of the San Juan River?” Ortega demanded.

Ortega said the Costa Rica border has been steadily encroaching northward for hundreds of years, as the San Juan River delta slowly dries out. However, he said, even though the historic river mouth has dried, it is still Nicaraguan territory.

“In the 1600s and 1700s, the river covered an enormous amount of territory at its delta,” Ortega said. “And as the zone has dried, the river has moved and (Costa Rica) has continued to advance and take possession of terrain that doesn’t belong to it. The way things are going, if the San Juan River continues to move north and join with the Río Grande of Matagalpa (in the northern zone), that’s how far (Costa Rica) would claim its territory extended.”

Ortega stressed that according to the July 2009 resolution from the International Court of Justice at The Hague, Nicaragua has the right to recuperate the historic delta of the San Juan River that existed more than 150 years ago.

“Nicaragua has the right to dredge the San Juan River to recover the flow of waters that existed in 1858, even if that affects the flow of water of other current recipients, such as the Colorado River,” Ortega said, reading from last year’s resolution for The Hague.

Ortega added that Costa Rica cannot impede such an operation in Nicaraguan territory.

To avoid confrontation, Ortega said The Hague should have the last word on the matter, because it already has all the information about the border conflict and its resolution from last year is “still fresh.” The OAS, on the other hand, is not informed about the border issue and has nothing relevant to say on the matter, Ortega said.

In calling on the International Court of Justice to mediate the issue, Ortega said that the border between Nicaragua and Costa Rica along the San Juan River needs to be marked once and for all to avoid bloodshed and conflicts in the future. He insisted that this will “not be provoked” by Costa Rican forces.

“We don’t want the blood of brothers to spill,” Ortega said.

  • Currently 5 out of 5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Rating: 5/5 (1 votes cast)

Thank you for rating!

You have already rated this page, you can only rate it once!

Your rating has been changed, thanks for rating!

Log in or create a user account to rate this page.

| Share

To comment, write a letter to the editor to letters@ticotimes.net. Please make sure to include your full name and location. Letters must be 500 words or fewer. Submissions should be original.

Log in or create a user account to comment.

Comments

Roan, the key word is "undocumented." I have, and have had, documented Nicaraguans working for me. I pay more than is required by law, and I am no slave driver. I know their value.
Just send a stream of about 10,000 UNDOCUMENTED to B del C and watch Ortega crawl back into his hole.
And by the way, that's a good idea: pull the all criminals out of the jails and mix them in with the others.
Edward, I completely agree! with you although don't be surprised to find more nationals in those hell-holes than foreigners.

Costa Rica will never kick out the immigrants 'cause the economy depends on it but they should certainly deport all criminals and social pariah... though I assume you're educated enough to realize not all Nicaraguans are members there and a large number (I know several) actually employ Costa Rican nationals and own large businesses and corporations.
Phil, I must apologize for I failed to notice the question marks and enquiring tone of your note.

The situation on crime in Nicaragua is pretty much like Costa Rica (I've visited and spent considerable time on both countries) where as they advise you to stay clear from Managua (capital) and some areas of the Atlantic Coast (due to Colombian/Mexican drug runners), but the tourist areas like Granada/Montelimar/San Juan del Sur/Leon/Marina Puesta del Sol and volcanoes/cloud forests/high lands are safe (obviously exercising common sense at all times like you would in Costa Rica).

The bus incident you are refering to was a politically charged situation where Ortega hired the lowest common denominator of the population (ie. turbas) to beat down the opposition (be it another party or labour unions, etc, but this always occurs in Managua and therefore transparent to tourists.

I find that tourists in Costa Rica are more of a target and robberies/aggravated assault do ocurr more often mostly due to the larger population of expats (thiefs know that's where the money is), where as in Nicaragua you see more petty pick-pockets.
Don't even argue with them. Let them sit there.
And on Saturday, go into every bar located south/southwest of parque central and detain all the undocumented. The next week, the construction sites, and then the coffee farms. Bus them in relays to Limon, put them on boats, take them to Barra del Colorado and let them start walking towards Nicaragua, wherever that may be. Once the dust settles, clean out La Carpio, Pavas, and other hell-holes and repeat the drill. And that's just the top of the list.
Keep it up until Ortega learns how to read a map.
Dear Paul,

I would think that after 28 years practicing law you would be more skilled at paying attention to detail, but then again maybe that is part of the job being a lawyer, to build a case so layered that the shaky ground it sits on is hard to identify or be questioned.

Unfortunately for you, I can also read and If you had bothered to look in detail at the boundary map on page 19 (or "boundry" as you call it) you would've realized rather quickly that the "tip" end of land shown is not the area in question (ie. Isla Calero) for you are refering to a much larger cross-section instead.

It appears that you are confusing the following (much larger) topographical perspective which corresponds to the area of bifurcation of San Juan with Colorado River ...

http://maps.google.ca/maps?f=q&source=s_q&hl=en&geocode=&q=isla+calero&sll=49.891235,-97.15369&sspn=27.954218,56.337891&ie=UTF8&hq=isla+calero&hnear=&t=h&safe=on&ll=10.833306,-83.71788&spn=0.333157,0.700378&z=11

... with the smaller cross-section corresponding to Isla Calero that sits in Nicaraguan territory as verified through Google maps (at least one institution here read the border treaties properly):

http://maps.google.ca/maps?f=q&source=s_q&hl=en&geocode=&q=isla+calero&sll=49.891235,-97.15369&sspn=27.954218,56.337891&safe=on&ie=UTF8&hq=isla+calero&hnear=&ll=10.922736,-83.686638&spn=0.041464,0.087547&t=h&z=14

The rest of the context in the treaty is not being challenged by anyone so not sure why you make reference, but it would help to remain objective and informed before spewing misguided opinions.
Roan Garcia,
1) I have no fishing business in Costa Rica-The boat and cabina are for my personal enjoyment and I travel to CR 4-5 times/year to enjoy them:
2) I have practiced law in Chicago for the past 28 years and I can read. I have studied the International Court of Justice (The Hague) decision of 13 July 2009 regarding the dispute and its History.In Detail. If can be viewed at www.icj-cij.org Ita a 58 page Judgment decision.I specifically refer you to p.19 (Boundry Map) and page 20 (Paragraph 19).It refers to,amongst other things,the duty to defend the common bay at San Juan del Norte.Costa Rica ratified the 1858 Treaty of Limits on 16 April 1858.Accordind to the International Court decision, Nicaragua ratified the border treaty 26 April 1858. Additionally,I will have you note that Nicaragua did not object to the International Court's jurisdiction or boundry map.And that was last year.Inded,if you read the decision iin its entirety you will find Nicaragua never has raised a boundry dispute (since 1858).
What you have been refering to is Nica disinformation. But don't just beleve me- I clearly must be part of that uninformed disinformation highway.YOU CAN READ IT YOURSELF
Roan, it wasn't to push my own agenda, that's why I had the question mark after the story about the two German girls, but it was on the news about 5 years ago. But the bus story is total true, angry protesters hurting their own people back in 2006. I watch a program on it last night on TV, saw the whole thing go down on video tape.

Nicaragua has been statistically shown to be the safest country in the region in 2006-2007. Although of late, recent crime reports show a higher rise in robbery and carjackings. This is why I ask if things are changing? Most crimes in Costa Rica is in the San Jose area, just avoid being there at night. But what I'm hearing Nicaragua has more problems in their jungle regions?, and that's were most tourist what to visit.
I took a look at Google maps (satellite view) and there it is clearly marked... Isla Calero is on Nicaraguan soil not Costa Rican... why all the fuss and pointless arguments only to cause self-embarrasment to the country?

http://maps.google.ca/maps?f=q&source=s_q&hl=en&geocode=&q=isla+calero&sll=49.891235,-97.15369&sspn=27.954218,56.337891&safe=on&ie=UTF8&hq=isla+calero&hnear=&ll=10.922736,-83.686638&spn=0.041464,0.087547&t=h&z=14

If you notice the border traces accross the canal that was being dredged, and not along the last 28 kilometers of the San Juan river as Costa Rica claims.
Phhil, you're either severely misinformed or you are willfully spreading false rumours to push your own agenda.

Nicaragua is rated the 2nd safest country in Latin America second only to Uruguay, Costa Rica could only dream of having the same crime rates as Nicaragua. It does't even matter that Costa Rica blames all the crimes on immigrants the fact is that drugs and kidnappings take place everywhere in Costa Rica while Nicaragua only suffers from political divisions (much like USA) but no major organized crime nor large numbher of murders per capita.

I don't agree with the Sandinista government (more like a pseudo-dictatorship) currently in place in Nicaragua but Costa Rica's curtain of smoke is but a cheap charade which will eventually be uncovered and many real Costa Ricans (not tourists) are aware that the country will likely suffer enbarrasment.
Paul, I will be the first to agree that President Ortega is not a democratically elected president but a corrupt pseudo-dictator... however, facts are facts and you need to get yourself properly informed instead of continuing the cycle of misinformation.

I understand that you have a vested interest since you own a small business in that area (small cabina and tarpon fishing boat) but you should've done your research properly and just because you and a bunch of villagers "thought" they lived in a specific country doesn't make it so.

The Cañas-Jerez treaty and Laudo Cleveland clearly state that Isla Calera belongs to Nicaragua, no "ifs" or "buts" about it. That has been the case since the late 1800's and simply because Costa Rica has resisted to accept it doesn't give it the right to take over what legally and rightfully belongs to Nicaragua.

The troops are in deed on Nicaraguan soil, the Costa Rican "police armed with war weaponry" trespassed unto foreign soil and are the ones who gravely violate international law.

Ortega has done nothing positive for his country, but in this case he just might inadvertently do so.

Weekend

Restaurants

Alquimia 1

An oasis away from city bustle and noise, Alquimia serves an eclectic mix of healthful dishes com...

Arts & Leisure

Gerald

More than 40 years ago, Gerald Brown made sweeping changes to the Costa Rican National Symphony O...

Travel

Hacienda Pinilla 1

Atlanta developer Hg Patillo bought a 4,500-acre farm in 1973; now it's an eco-friendly and luxur...

Fishing Fishing Forum

Fishing Todd

A new satellite technology will help track, count and conserve billfish.