News Briefs

Costa Rica, Guatemala leaders slam drug report

Posted: Monday, June 06, 2011 - By Alex Leff
In a meeting with Laura Chinchilla in Costa Rica, Guatemala's President Álvaro Colom criticized a report suggesting legalizing certain narcotics would reduce violence in Central America.
Colom and Chinchilla
AFP

Guatemalan President Alvaro Colom, left, is welcomed by his Costa Rican counterpart Laura Chinchilla at the presidential palace in San Jose, on Sunday morning. Colom arrived in Costa Rica to discuss regional and bilateral issues.

Central American presidents lambasted a new report by a high-level drug policy group that calls for an end to the war on drugs and urges countries to try legal regulation of certain narcotics.

“I think all presidents have the temptation of legalizing drugs so that this violence finally leaves us alone,” Guatemalan President Álvaro Colom said on Sunday while visiting Costa Rica. “However, I believe that it is not the right path. The right path is to fight all together against drug trafficking in the area.”

But last week a group of former and current world leaders, experts, entrepreneurs and intellectuals called the Global Commission on Drug Policy issued a report in New York saying that model has failed.

Among the members are former United Nations Secretary General Kofi Annan, United States’ ex-Secretary of State George Schultz and former Federal Reserve chief Paul Volcker, former Brazilian President Fernando Henrique Cardoso and billionaire co-founder of U.K. company Virgin, Richard Branson.

“Fifty years after the initiation of the U.N. Single Convention on Narcotics Drugs and 40 years after President (Richard) Nixon launched the U.S. government's global war on drugs, fundamental reforms in national and global drug control policies are urgently needed,” said Cardoso in a statement.

“Let’s start by treating drug addiction as a health issue, reducing drug demand through educational initiatives and legally regulating rather than criminalizing cannabis,” the former Brazilian leader added.

The message, pushing for a “paradigm shift” in nations’ approach to dealing with narcotics problems that favors health care and prevention over law enforcement, is not new but the high profile of its backers added weight to the report.

Costa Rican President Laura Chinchilla, who joined Colom during Sunday’s press briefing, ratcheted up the level of criticism against the drug commission.

She said Costa Rica has already decriminalized marijuana use, but she slammed the idea of legalizing the sale of the drug. That misses the point of how organized criminals work, she said.

“It seems to me naïve for those who say ‘let’s legalize all the marijuana and watch (illicit) earnings drop,’” Chinchilla said. “(Criminals) will move to harder drugs, and the resulting situation will be worse, because it will open up larger consumer markets for hard drugs.”

She said Central America is already grappling with the trafficking and related violence of hard drugs such as cocaine. Central America is struggling to repel deadly drug cartels in turf wars over this critical drug-trafficking route from southern producing nations to rich consumers.

Chinchilla stressed that 90 percent of the United States’ cocaine supply runs through Central American countries like Costa Rica but these developing isthmus nations spend 40 times the amount of money donated here in foreign aid to crack down on drug cartels.

“Something I don’t understand is why are they advocating for this as ex-presidents and not while they were president,” Chinchilla said.

  • Currently 0 out of 5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Rating: 0/5 (0 votes cast)

Thank you for rating!

You have already rated this page, you can only rate it once!

Your rating has been changed, thanks for rating!

Log in or create a user account to rate this page.

| Share

To comment, write a letter to the editor to letters@ticotimes.net. Please make sure to include your full name and location. Letters must be 500 words or fewer. Submissions should be original.

Log in or create a user account to comment.

Comments

Anyone who does not appreciate the simple economic facts of capitalism, cannot make out why outlawing drugs like alcohol, spawn huge criminal enterprises. It also spawns huge side markets, like Eliott Ness. It has become a VERY profitable business for both government and criminals as they continue their mutually complimentary roles in this play.

Take away profit motive, and you kill drug sales organizations. No super risk, no super profit. No huge government internal police agencies. No criminal addicts selling their bodies, mugging passerby's and raiding houses. None of that. No drug murders for drugs cut too much with sugar, etc.

The first writer has it right, Jose Solano. My heart goes out to the people of Central America and their exploitation by drug lords of government and drug cartels. Many once innocents are corrupted daily by this gambit.
Now why would the governments of Guatemala, Mexico, etc. want to undermine such a lucrative business, one in which so many of their officials greatly profit?

What do mere "intellectuals" like former United Nations Secretary General Kofi Annan, United States’ ex-Secretary of State George Schultz and former Federal Reserve chief Paul Volcker, former Brazilian President Fernando Henrique Cardoso and billionaire co-founder of U.K. company Virgin, Richard Branson know about the problem?

After all, we can compare a crime against oneself, drug taking, with crimes against others, "murder, death squads, genocide, rape, and many other atrocities." I'm sure the drug cartels and the government officials that support them simply love this kind of reasoning.

“Something I don’t understand is why are they advocating for this as ex-presidents and not while they were president,” Chinchilla said. That's a very good question.

In addition to Fernando Henrique Cardoso I understand that the Commission includes former presidents Ernesto Zedillo of Mexico, César Gaviria of Colombia, and former president Ruth Dreifuss of Switzerland.

It does includes such "intellectuals"—for some a pejorative term—as Mario Vargas Llosa and Carlos Fuentes. It also includes the current Prime Minister of Greece George Papandreou.

Of course most active politicians do not see it as politically advantageous to take on such a controversial subject. You would have to reason against the intensive propaganda the public has been fed for over 50 years in the failed and often hypocritical government policies to control drugs.

I would imagine that the legalization of drugs would so adversely affect the drug business that it could destabilize the economies of entire nations. So does it really matter to the politicians of a nation if they protect their personal and national economic interests even if thousands of people are killed over the years and terror is spread throughout the country?

Certainly if legalization is ever to occur it should ideally start in the US but other nations don't have to wait for the US.

BTW, the full report of the Global Commission on Drug Policy, in English and Spanish, can be found here: http://www.globalcommissionondrugs.org/Report

Actually, legallizing drugs is the answer. The governments could then control the distribution, prevent minors from using, and apply hefty taxes. The drug cartels would go out of business. And the taliban would no longer make money on the opium/poppy trade. The governmetns could then stop wasting money on the war on drugs and actually have revenue generated from the taxes to spend on helping addicts and promoting responsible use. This is no different than the alcohol prohibition in the US 80 years ago. Right now it's easier for a 14 year old to get a joint than cigarettes. This war is obviously not working and no amount of money or CIA ops are going to stop it. Instead, let's put our money and efforts into stopping human trafficking. Now that's a serious crime needs to be stopped.
The drug cartels are involved in people smuggling, weapons trafficking, extortion, protection rackets. prostitution and every other type of money making crime so a smart person looks past the drug issue that too many try to concentrate on.
I too admire President Chinchilla for her work in bringing more foreign companies to Costa Rica. But I think she is wrong in the war on drugs. Could this be because the war on drugs is a growth industry? Costa Ricans were very proud of saying they had more teachers than soldiers. Is this true still today? By what I see on Telenoticias, almost every segment is dedicated to drug crime.
As Mr Hardin has stated: The war on drugs has failed. What a waist of money, so let's just keep on trucking with the same old same. But I guess with due respect to President Chinchilla, she must be smarter than the members of the Global Commission On Drug Policy!
The more I see our President in action the more I admire her and her commitment to try to do what is right for her country, even the unpopular but necessary stuff. In spite of its problems, I believe Costa Rica is a much more responsible and honest democracy than many countries would have us believe.

These are just my thoughts, right or wrong…

Legalizing drugs is not the answer; nor is legalizing murder, death squads, genocide, rape, and many other atrocities. Everything we understand as rational human beings tells us this just as surely as we know not to stick our hand into the fire. Only an “intellectual” would come up with a plan so utterly irresponsible. Only the wealthy or politicians would be devious enough to support it, knowing the true outcome of such a decision. Is it possible that the idea is only presented through this “prestigious” group to give it legitimacy, but actually came from somewhere else? A group with more “personal” interests in mind?

President Chinchilla brings up an excellent question, and one at the very heart of the matter. Virtually the entire drug supply is destined for North America, yet the war to stop it is mostly forced on the governments of Latin America. Why? They are not causing the problem, but simply victims in the line of fire, collateral damage.

Personally, I have no conviction the governments of North America have any interest in stopping the drug torrent into North America. Addiction, crime, violence, and destruction of the family and society are slowly but surely destroying the middle class, democracy, and freedom. Is it so hard to believe that there are people that would like to see men subjugated, maybe even all men? Haven’t we’ve seen it before, or at least the “public face” of it?

President Chinchilla has every right to voice skepticism, and thank goodness she’s tough enough and still unfettered enough to speak her mind about it.
legalizing marijuana wouldn't have any effect on drug trafficking in Central America. Marijuana is not the problem. Pot users in the USA don't even smoke the crappy stuff that's grown in Mexico or any other Central or south American country. This is totally irrelevant to the cocaine problem.

On the other hand, if native Costa Ricans want to smoke pot I don't see what the problem is? Alcohol consumption is far worse than smoking a little weed. Hemp can be a useful product as well.
The War on Drugs failed Billions of dollars ago! This money could have been used for outreach programs to clean up the bad end of drug abuse by providing free HIV testing, free rehab, and clean needles. Harmless drugs like marijuana could be legalized to help boost our damaged economy. Cannabis can provide hemp for countless natural recourses and the tax revenue from sales alone would pull every state in our country out of the red! Vote Teapot, PASS IT, and legalize it. Voice you opinion with the movement and check out my pro-cannabis art at http://dregstudiosart.blogspot.com/2011/01/vote-teapot-2011.html

Weekend

Restaurants

Alquimia 1

An oasis away from city bustle and noise, Alquimia serves an eclectic mix of healthful dishes com...

Arts & Leisure

 Fire station’s miniature museum

AROUND COSTA RICA: The Atenas fire station has a nifty little secret.

Travel

Tortuga Lodge 1

Eco-luxury and wildlife encounters abound at this remote jungle escape.

Fishing Fishing Forum

Fishing Todd

A new satellite technology will help track, count and conserve billfish.