Costa Rica’s Supreme Court to hear challenges to anti-IVF lawmakers

November 30, 2015

Six plaintiffs are asking Costa Rica’s Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court, or Sala IV, to throw out a constitutionality challenge to an executive decree that would legalize in vitro fertilization (IVF) in Costa Rica.

The Ombudsman’s Office, Fundación Déjame Vivir en Paz, the Center for Justice and International Law, the Doctors and Surgeons Association, the National Women’s Institute, and Boris Molina, a lawyer representing couples who filed a petition at the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACHR), each submitted requests asking Sala IV justices to dismiss a claim filed by lawmakers from four parties in October.

In a 4-3 vote in October, Sala IV justices agreed to temporarily suspend the process to reinstate IVF procedures pending a final ruling on the lawmakers’ complaint, which argues that IVF can only be regulated by law and not by decree.

President Luis Guillermo Solís on Sept. 11 signed a decree to legalize IVF in Costa Rica, where it was banned in 2000 by a Sala IV ruling. Solís’ decree was an effort to come into compliance with an IACHR ruling in 2012, which on Saturday, Nov. 28 marked its three-year anniversary.

The president’s order establishes a six-month deadline for the Health Ministry to outline all technical rules and protocols for transferring eggs, and asks the Social Security System to restart assisted fertilization procedures within the next two years.

The San José-based human rights court sent two separate requests on Sept. 25 and Oct. 9 asking Costa Rica’s government to explain its advances in legalizing and offering IVF services, and the country’s efforts to pass legislation to regulate it.

The government on Oct. 15 submitted a report highlighting that the Solís decree brought Costa Rica into compliance with the court’s orders. The response also stated that both the Social Security System and the Public Health Ministry are working on outlining technical procedures for reinstating IVF.

Sala IV justices do not have a deadline to issue a ruling on the lawmakers’ complaint.

You may be interested

New poll in Costa Rica shows huge surge for evangelical pastor
Elections 2018
1343 views
Elections 2018
1343 views

New poll in Costa Rica shows huge surge for evangelical pastor

AFP - January 23, 2018

While nearly a third of Costa Rican voters remain undecided less than two weeks before the presidential and legislative elections,…

Tamarindo gears up for Art Wave Festival
Arts & Culture
665 views
Arts & Culture
665 views

Tamarindo gears up for Art Wave Festival

Ellen Zoe Golden - January 23, 2018

Tamarindo is preparing for another cultural immersion: the 2018 Tamarindo Art Wave is coming to town on Jan. 25-27. This…

VIDEO: Will Costa Rica recognize this same-sex marriage?
Human rights
1659 views
Human rights
1659 views

VIDEO: Will Costa Rica recognize this same-sex marriage?

Elizabeth Lang - January 22, 2018

The Inter-American Court of Human Rights (CIDH) ruled Jan. 9 that all member states, including Costa Rica, must recognize same-sex…