San José, Costa Rica, since 1956
Op-Ed

Six years later, what impact has CAFTA had on Costa Rica?

In recent years, the rhetoric in Costa Rica regarding the Dominican Republic-Central American Free-Trade Agreement with the United States (CAFTA-DR) has died down as the impact of full implementation has extended across the country. Almost six years into the agreement, Costa Rica has a large stake in CAFTA’s success, and whether you are for or against the controversial trade pact, there is no doubt that some good has been created as a result of its implementation. From the increase in high-skilled labor to an increasingly diversified economy, CAFTA has brought Costa Rica a measure of economic stability.

CAFTA has served as a tool in Costa Rica’s ongoing, long-term process of becoming less reliant on tourism and moving toward an economy with higher-paying, more stable jobs. In addition, farmers and manufacturers are finding and taking advantage of new customers abroad; CAFTA has opened the door to foreign investors as money has poured into creating manufacturing centers, call centers, and other facilities employing thousands of Costa Ricans. This has contributed to Costa Rica’s overall economic growth, as demonstrated by growth in GDP – the measure is forecasted to increase by 4.3 percent in 2015, up from 3.7 percent in 2014 – as well as by increased employment in business services, knowledge-intensive services, education, medicine and the public sector.

Unsurprisingly, Costa Rica and the United States have established themselves as the leading players within the agreement, as 40 percent of all CAFTA exports to the United States come from this country. Since CAFTA took effect, Costa Rica has established a trade surplus with the United States of $4.7 billion in 2013, effectively leveraging its position within CAFTA.

However, with advantages come disadvantages. CAFTA has caused a well-documented increase in trade across all of Central America, but it has also created an unintended side effect. As a result of increased exports to the United States and foreign investment in Costa Rica by U.S. companies, Costa Rica has put many of its economic eggs into the U.S. basket. A large percentage of Costa Rica’s GDP is tied to CAFTA-related activities, with U.S. exports reaching $11.9 billion, or 19.46 percent of the country’s GDP in 2013, and imports from the United States accounting for $7.2 billion, or 11.7 percent of GDP. The 2008 global finance crisis proves how great an impact economic downturns can have on interconnected economies; tying such a large amount of a country’s GDP to trade with one country is the precise recipe for eventual economic hardship.

Another unintended consequence of CAFTA has been the persistent brain drain occurring across the country. Although not a new phenomenon, Costa Rica has seen a large exit of its talented young people for “greener pastures” and more lucrative opportunities in countries like the United States. With their exit comes a loss of creative and intelligent leaders, entrepreneurs and other potential innovators. CAFTA and the foreign companies welcomed by the trade agreement have made Costa Ricans’ exit easier with companies like Bank of America, Citibank, HP and others recruiting the top talent for their operations in the United States and beyond. Without similar and ongoing opportunities at home in Costa Rica, the exit of talented Costa Ricans will continue, thus potentially damaging the national economy for decades.

As for those Ticos who have stayed behind, they face the growing concern of inequality between the rich and the poor. As seen in countries like the United States and other developed and developing economies, this growing gap can be attributed to the globalization of the world’s economies and the wealth it brings to the upper echelons of society, while others in the lower classes are faced with insufficient wages or long-term unemployment. This rings true for Costa Rica. Unemployment continues to remain high at 7.9 percent in 2013, up from 7.8 percent in 2012. Although it is the Central American country that has gained the most from CAFTA, Costa Rica still has the second-highest unemployment rate in the region.

Overall, the CAFTA-DR agreement as brought Costa Rica economic success. The country has added more high-skilled jobs and increased exports of agricultural and manufactured goods, and it’s clear the current trade surplus with the United States will continue to add to Costa Rica’s GDP. However, with lagging unemployment and almost 20 percent of the country’s GDP generated from exports and investment with the United States, Costa Rica’s economic foundation could tumble quickly. With such a large amount of economic activity associated to trade with one country, any decrease or change in trading patterns could have an immense impact on the Costa Rican economy.

The weak, underperforming job market will only make matters worse. Costa Rica needs to take the opportunity to learn from its newly diversified economy by continuing to be innovative and push for the continued advancement of the Costa Rican economy by becoming less reliant on the United States. Otherwise, the short-term gains from CAFTA-DR could become a long-term liability.

Melanie Furey is a research professional from Cleveland, Ohio, working abroad in Ciudad Colón, where she is conducting independent research on U.S. foreign policy, Costa Rica and Central American issues and other related topics. She holds a bachelor’s degree in economics from Allegheny College and a master’s degree in international relations from Cleveland State University.

Log in to comment

Ken Morris

I’m lost. Since the article cites the (surely not unbiased) post from the US Trade Representative, let me paste that link here again:

http://www.ustr.gov/countries-regions/americas/costa-rica

Wait a second. So Costa Rica is exporting about the same amount of oil to the US as it imports? Did someone discover oil in Costa Rica and I not hear about it?

The benchmark year of 2003 is also suspicious. Why that year? Come on.

We also know that overall Costa Rica has had an increasingly negative trade balance since CAFTA. Is this because of the Chinese?

And it frankly looks like most of this trade is within multinationals. What independent medical device exporting company exists in Costa Rica?

I like facts, even statistical ones, and have read other reports on CAFTA (that invariably are produced by its proponents). But if you look at it, the big FDI has been in telecommunications–a one-time thing in which foreign companies are planning to take their profits home with them–but not much that benefits Costa Rica

0 0
DRMeno

THE USA had put Oscar in power to pass the CAFTA. Yes they corrupt the politics here too.

0 0
DRMeno

This report is very bias. B of A and Citibank are corporate criminals that destroy forgone economies. CAFTA brought more poison from the USA. With more fast foods and Fluoride in your salt to stupidly the people, like the Hormigas in the USA. It has open the door for GMO foods, and other toxic ins in our environment. It made us switch to SKY TV and through out Direct TV’s south American feed, to SKY’s north Americans advertisers products and goods and services. It has polluted our skyline with cell towers emitting micro waves harmful to out health. It has Contributed to the take over of forge n banks in CR. AND there are many hidden. It will turn CR into another Banana Republic bringing Fascism to CR.

0 0
DRMeno

It has also open the SPY network into CR to trap ex pats that want nothing to do with the USA. CR is now mostly covered with the SPY CLOUD network of the NSA.
NASA to NSA, The Global Cloud Spy Network
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ygyRyalX1N4

0 0
Stephen Johnson

Where is our US Ambassador? It has been almost two years – we are the largest trading partner for the US within CAFTA-DR and we get treated like a second class citizen. Shameful. Good thing President Solis is looking to broaden our economic base with stronger ties to China!

0 0
DRMeno

AND Sois needs to break ties with the USA and open more ties with South America. CAFTA seeks to destroy that relation we had with South America.

0 0