San José, Costa Rica, since 1956
Economy

World Bank official: Costa Rica faces some painful choices in 2015

WASHINGTON, D.C. – Costa Rica’s top diplomat in Washington and the World Bank’s top regional official agree on just about everything: President Luis Guillermo Solís – in office now for seven months – must cut spending, boost tax collection and cut the nation’s fiscal deficit-to-GDP ratio, which appears unsustainable in the long run.

But Humberto López, the World Bank’s director for Central America, warned that some people aren’t taking the crisis seriously enough.

“Talking to others, I don’t feel there’s a sense this is really important,” he said Wednesday. “Costa Rica is projected to have a 6.7 percent deficit next year, and the government understands all this – but not everyone has that same sense of urgency.”

López spoke along with Román Macaya, Costa Rica’s ambassador to the United States, at a roundtable organized by Inter-American Dialogue and attended by 25 people. Moderating the panel was Michael Shifter, president of the Washington-based think tank.

Macaya, recalling the “extraordinary election” of Solís, who had barely registered in the polls two months earlier, said his president has faced one crisis after another since his May 8 inauguration.

“There was no honeymoon,” Macaya told his audience of executives, diplomats and NGO representatives. “He inherited a teachers’ strike, and since then, there’s been a second strike, by port workers, and a lot of uncertainty.”

Even so, the ambassador said Costa Rica’s Central Bank is projecting growth of 3.5 percent next year, with the World Bank pegging 2015 growth at closer to 4 percent – thanks to the recovering U.S. economy and a sharp drop in crude oil prices.

Macaya said Costa Rica would likely end up with a fiscal deficit of around 5.8 percent of gross domestic product – somewhat lower than what was initially expected.

“This is due to austerity measures, but also improved tax collection methods,” he said. “Costa Rica has never sent anyone to jail for evading taxes, [but] there are now five cases, and fear is a motivator. This has helped increase tax revenues and lower the deficit a little bit.”

Nevertheless, he insists the focus must be on collecting more taxes to begin with.

“We have had ongoing discussions with the IMF on further measures to take place over the next four years,” Macaya explained. “The idea is to cut the deficit by an additional 3.75 percent of GDP. One reform is an anti-tax evasion law that gives greater teeth to our equivalent of the IRS. Another is a project to convert Costa Rica’s sales tax into a value-added tax. Our economy is dominated today by services, yet it contributes less to tax revenues than manufacturing or agriculture. This VAT will go a long way toward creating a more just system among tax contributors.”

Putting things in perspective, the World Bank’s López argues that Costa Rica ranks way better than most of its neighbors in nearly every quality-of-life index.

“Looking at the OECD as a model, Costa Rica has the same problems many rich countries have. Its problems are closer to the problems of Spain than those of other Latin American countries, so cutting the deficit can be a real challenge,” said López, a Spanish national who oversees World Bank operations not only for Costa Rica but also for El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, Nicaragua and Panama.

“In Costa Rica, inequality is lower than the rest of Latin America,” he said. “Also, labor productivity in Costa Rica has increased by 40 percent since 2001. This is significant, because growth has not been driven by an increase in population, but rather by increases in productivity. And it’s happening at all levels of the labor market, both skilled and unskilled.”

The result is a dramatic increase in the service sector, which now accounts for 70 percent of Costa Rica’s economy, compared to agriculture, with only a 10 percent share. And that service sector needs to pay its fair share of taxes, said López.

“This will require legislative changes in tax and spending policy that in a political environment is difficult,” warned the official, emphasizing that these changes should be done over a three- to four-year period. “It would be a total mistake to try to do it in one or two years. Probably two-thirds of this [revenue] should come from additional taxes, and one-third from spending cuts. We have been talking with authorities about these issues.”

Macaya agreed, noting that barely 20 years ago, bananas, pineapples and coffee were the country’s main exports by value; today, medical devices such as pacemakers, catheters and surgical instruments top the list.

“Services are under-represented as tax contributors,” he said, explaining why a value-added tax is the way to go. “Even if there’s no change in the percentage from a sales tax to a VAT, suddenly all these services which dominate Costa Rica’s economy will be taxable. Companies most affected will be those not paying much in taxes today.”

But, the ambassador added: “Our president has to take this to the people. It’ll be a difficult sell in a democracy. This is not going to be pain-free.”

Log in to comment

Ken Morris

I too have my reservations about the World Bank. (However, it is not 100% controlled by the US government. The US is dominant, with around 30% of the control, double the control of the second most powerful member state, Japan, but it doesn’t have 100% of the control.) But I don’t think anything in this article is, or should be, controversial.

Everyone knows that Costa Rica is in a public budgeting mess, and some mix of increased tax collections and spending cuts are probably in order. Mind, I’m not so sure that I agree with the spending cuts, whatever they may be, since I doubt the cuts will be effected in the right areas. The waste seems to me to be in the fat salaries and pensions for a small segment of the public employees, but this is probably the hardest area to cut, since these folks can just run to the Sala IV and win. “Austerity” will probably therefore be achieved but cutting the lowest-ranking employees who actually deliver public services. Not good. It’s really better to increase tax collections.

And note that I say tax COLLECTIONS, not taxes. I’m not at all convinced that taxes need to be increased, since I suspect that simply collecting the bulk of the taxes already owed but evaded will solve the problem.

Those in the article are overly polite to reference tax collection in “services” as a problem, when this is a little misleading. No school teachers or call center employees are evading taxes, since they can’t. The “services” at issue are the independent professionals–doctors, dentists, lawyers, and even accountants. Tax evasion is rampant among these folks.

I went to a dentist the other day. He took cash and provided no receipt. Now, what do we think is going on? OK, he may have a mistress with expensive tastes to support along with his family. but he’s still flagrantly cheating on taxes.

Let’s wait till the World Bank gives bad advice before we pounce on it. In this case, it seems to be telling it like it is.

0 0
David Boddiger

Thanks, Ken. Interesting thoughts.

0 0
DRMeno

The hard choice would be to through the Hefe of the central bank in JAIL, like Iceland did.

0 0
DRMeno

BEN, Thank you for being awake down here. YOU ARE SO RIGHT ON. These IMF and World BAnk ban$ters criminals are destroying the world. NOW they have there grubby mittens in CR. They will repossess the country one day. Like Greece and Cyprus and cities and counties in the USA. So they brought down the poisons from the USA with CAFTA. Starting the SLOW KILL process. Bankrupt the CAJA with sick and addicted people. Then CAJA needs to barrow more money . Watch these videos on this subject.

Austerity in Costa Rica, How the Presidents Sold the Country, Chinchilla, Arias.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FPRQD9-KmK4

Rothschild NWO has Fiscal Control. NOW for Physical Dominance.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ToY589X0FSE

Stockton Bankrupt, Pensions Stolen by Bank$ters
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NikZvGhnN_w

Bank$ters Will Repossess Your Cities, Counties, & States. Buying up bonds, cents 2 $$’s.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-rqqw63EDxs

QE3, And the Repossession of USA
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xgiPD-w23Eo

The Fiscal Revolution, The Peaceful Revolution, & Bank Runs
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cLwb49IRXS0

0 0
Ben

World Bank is such a bad thing it makes most leaders scared when they come to talking about countries debt. The world bank is 100% controlled by the US goverment and if they want to hurt people in country send in the world bank. Look at Greece and Italy and spain all there problems where caused because of the world bank. Please tell Prez of CR avoid the World Bank and IMF. These banks are so bad for any country. BRIC nations might be better to talk to now more than the corupt world bank.

0 0