Lawyer in Crucitas fight goes to court for defamation charges

January 28, 2015

One of the environmental lawyers who has led the fight against gold mining at Las Crucitas near the Nicaraguan border appeared in court Monday to face accusations he defamed the mining company, Industrias Infinito.

“It was only a few things I said to a newspaper of national circulation,” said Edgardo Araya after his appearance in the Justice Courts of Goicochea. “And they interpreted it as offensive.”

Neither Araya nor lawyers for Crucitas would address what the alleged defamatory comments were.

Industrias Infinito is a subsidiary of the Canadian mining company Infinito Gold, Inc. The company has been trying to extractgold from a site near Las Crucitas for more than a decade. Those plans were struck down by the Supreme Court’s Civil and Administrative Law Branch (Sala I) in November of 2010. The company has appealed that decision.

Araya and other lawyers battling against the Crucitas mine, which was first proposed in 1993 and was declared to be in the public interest by former president Óscar Arias in 2006, petitioned the Sala I last week to dismiss any pending appeals by Infinito Gold. This came after allegations that Moisés Fachler, a substitute judge in the previous Crucitas trial allegedly leaked a draft of a ruling by the Sala I to representatives of Industrias Infinito last October.

After Monday’s hearing Industrias Infinito’s lawyer, Ciro Casas, declined to comment on the case. Araya’s legal team would only say Industrias Infinito had offered to settle the matter, but the two sides could not agree on terms.

“It was a great opportunity to arrive at some type of agreement,” Araya said. “However, the terms they wanted to work out were impossible for us… We’ll take it to the judge.”

Infinito Gold is seeking damages, according to Araya’s advisers, of up to $1 million. Before the hearing Araya said he feels the mining company is waging a campaign of fear through legal intimidation in hopes of silencing critics like him.

You may be interested

Our High Season Print Edition is here! Here’s where to find it
The Tico Times
199 views
The Tico Times
199 views

Our High Season Print Edition is here! Here’s where to find it

Katherine Stanley - December 11, 2017

In the weeks since the relaunch of The Tico Times on Sept. 1, we’ve been hard at work to reconnect…

Bright Lights Boat Parade inaugurates holiday season in Quepos
Events
299 views
Events
299 views

Bright Lights Boat Parade inaugurates holiday season in Quepos

Elizabeth Lang - December 11, 2017

The Bright Lights Boat Parade marked the official kickoff of the holiday season in the Central Pacific town of Quepos…

Strong winds cause three deaths in Costa Rica, one in El Salvador
Weather
2709 views
Weather
2709 views

Strong winds cause three deaths in Costa Rica, one in El Salvador

AFP - December 10, 2017

Three people have died in Costa Rica, includiing two Swiss tourists, and one in El Salvador as a result of…