Proposed Telecom Law Splits CAFTA Coalition

November 9, 2007

The opening of the state telecommunications monopoly – alternatively loved and despised by cell phone users – is perhaps the most controversial requirement in the Central American Free-Trade Agreement with the United States (CAFTA).

A proposal to take that monopoly away from the Costa Rican Electricity Institute (ICE) – one of 11 bills in the so-called CAFTA implementation agenda – has created rifts even within the coalition of 38 legislators who support the free-trade agreement.

The Libertarian Movement Party (ML) disagrees with provisions in the telecommunications bill pushed by the National Liberation Party (PLN) and the Social Christian Unity Party (PUSC).

The bill has already been approved by a special legislative commission and is ready for debate by the full Legislative Assembly.

The Citizen Action Party (PAC), which opposes CAFTA, has vowed to vote against any version of the bill. Meanwhile, the Libertarians, a crucial ally in the 38-member bloc, are suggesting substantial changes, prompting Liberation and PUSC to say they are willing to negotiate – to a point.

First, the Libertarians say the bill errs in allowing political bodies – the executive branch and the newly enhanced Ministry of the Environment, Energy and Telecommunications (MINAET) – to give companies concessions to the radio spectrum. Libertarians argue that the Public Services Regulatory Authority (ARESEP), an apolitical body that regulates public services, should give the concessions.

Lorena Vázquez, PUSC faction head, said she would not negotiate that point because, she said, the Constitution mandates that a political body authorize concessions. But she said other parts of the bill are open to discussion.

“As long as (the law) has the same spirit, if there are some things we can negotiate on, of course we will,” Vázquez said.

One sticking point is rates for consumers. Under the PUSC-PLN bill, a branch of ARESEP would fix rates until the telecommunications market became truly competitive.

The Libertarians want rates to be fixed for just two years. After that, companies should be able to decide their own prices, notwithstanding the state of the market.

The Libertarians also say the bill charges companies too much in taxes and sanctions.

Under the PUSC-PLN bill, for example, companies would pay between 2-4% of their income to a state fund that would provide telecommunication services to rural areas, where private companies may not want to set up shop. The Libertarians want to lower that fee to between 1% and 2%.

At the end of the day, Libertarian legislator Carlos Gutiérrez said the party would support the bill as written. But not without a fight.

 

Facebook Comments

You may be interested

In context: Costa Rica’s struggles with indigenous land rights
Costa Rica
791 views
Costa Rica
791 views

In context: Costa Rica’s struggles with indigenous land rights

The Tico Times - March 19, 2019

Sergio Rojas, a leader of the Bribrí community in Costa Rica, was murdered Monday night in the indigenous territory of…

‘A tragic day for the Bribrí people’ as leader Sergio Rojas is killed
Costa Rica
3504 views
Costa Rica
3504 views

‘A tragic day for the Bribrí people’ as leader Sergio Rojas is killed

Alejandro Zúñiga - March 19, 2019

Sergio Rojas, a leader of the indigenous Bribrí community in Costa Rica, was murdered Monday night, the government confirmed. Rojas…

This week in the Peace Corps: Sports for youth development
Changemakers
441 views
Changemakers
441 views

This week in the Peace Corps: Sports for youth development

Susan W. / Peace Corps Volunteer - March 19, 2019

Some rural communities struggle with lack of resources and recreational activities. In my experience, the majority of the people in…