Vegetable Protections: New CAFTA Battleground?

March 30, 2007

Opponents of the Central American Free-Trade Agreement (CAFTA) are trying to uproot a bill in the Legislative Assembly intended to promote research and development in seed technology as part of CAFTA reforms.

The proposal, which would protect the developer of a new seed variety’s exclusive right to sell that variety for up to 25 years, has CAFTA opponents defending small farmers and Costa Rica’s food security.

“This project attempts to patent seeds and plants, to hand them over to transnational companies from the United States and steal them from the people of Costa Rica,” Broad Front legislator José Merino said in a statement.

The bill includes jail time as punishment for those who don’t respect the protections – a part of the proposal even supporters say they are trying to change.

As part of CAFTA, which Costa Rica has signed but not ratified, the country agreed to pass 13 other bills along with the trade pact. Under CAFTA and in accordance with a 1991 international agreement, Costa Rica must pass a law that would give the developers of new seed varieties the exclusive right to market them for up to 25 years.

“It’s an attempt to support those who develop new varieties, so the costly process of investment is protected,” said National Liberation Party (PLN) legislator Salvador Quirós. Quirós, who is the president of the assembly’s Agriculture, Fishing and Natural Resources Commission debating the proposal, said the bill is important for the development of new seed varieties to battle disease and plagues that have ravaged Costa Rican farms in recent years, he said. He added that six of the nine commission members support the proposal, but it hasn’t yet been brought to a vote.

Anti-CAFTA legislators from the opposition Citizen Action Party (PAC) have presented most of the approximately 80 motions to that project in the commission.

To speed up the debate, the assembly voted March 22 to put a one-month time limit on the commission’s discussion of the proposal before voting on it.

At a press conference at the Legislative Assembly Wednesday, CAFTA opponents gathered to show their unified disapproval of the proposal.

“Should our seeds, our plants, be in the hands of our people, our citizens, or in the hands of a few?” said anti-CAFTA activist Cesar López, who heads the Cultural Movement against CAFTA. He was flanked by Merino, PAC legislators and anti-CAFTA educators from the country’s public universities.

Pro-CAFTA Libertarian Movement legislator Ovidio Aguero, who is also on the commission, denied allegations that the proposal would restrict farmers’ abilities to replant seeds from plants grown from protected seeds they bought in previous years.

However, Aguero did acknowledge the need to include more protections for small farmers. He said he is working with the National Seed Office to develop a motion or motions to change the bill to define what is a small farmer and give small farmers the ability to “freely exchange” protected seeds among themselves.

 

You may be interested

Adaptive surfing, part III: Riding the waves with Noah
sports
118 views
sports
118 views

Adaptive surfing, part III: Riding the waves with Noah

Ellen Zoe Golden - May 25, 2018

Part III in a series on adaptive surfing in Costa Rica. Read Part I, about the country's association for disabled…

It’s frog orgy season
Environment and Wildlife
1223 views
Environment and Wildlife
1223 views

It’s frog orgy season

Lindsay Fendt - May 25, 2018

The rainy season is upon us. For many of us that means hiding indoors for the next few months, but for Costa…

Costa Rica’s guilty voters
No Sugar Please
185 views
No Sugar Please
185 views

Costa Rica’s guilty voters

Álvaro Murillo - May 25, 2018

By what I have done, and by what I have left undone. A relative of mine is 70 years old…