Constitutional Chamber Reinforces Noise-Limit Order

May 12, 2006

The Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court (Sala IV) has ruled in favor of a couple who claims the horn of the San José train makes too much noise and prevents their baby girl from sleeping. The ruling reinforces an order emitted by Sala IV justices when the suit was first filed.

The court ruled that the Costa Rican Railroad Institute (INCOFER) must reduce the horn from current levels of as much as 120 decibels to “reasonable limits,” according to the daily La Nación, and eventually place lights at intersections of streets with the train line, which runs from the eastern San José suburb of San Pedro to the western suburb of Pavas.

Pedro Chaves and Alejandra Castro, who live 20 meters from the train tracks in Sabana Sur, a western San José neighborhood, filed the suit against INCOFER earlier this year. Sala IV justices agreed to study the suit and issued an immediate order to INCOFER to comply with Health Ministry noise regulations (TT, March 24). Chaves told La Nación he is pleased that the court recognized rights to “a healthy environment,” but criticized the ruling for not indicating a deadline by which INCOFER must comply.

INCOFER President Miguel Carabaguíaz criticized the ruling for not specifying the levels to which the institute must reduce the horn, and told the daily that reducing the volume could cause more accidents because drivers don’t respect road signs. However, the earlier Sala IV order specified that the horn must comply with Public Health Ministry industrial noise regulations (65 decibels between 6 a.m. and 6 p.m., and 45 decibels overnight).

Since the diesel train, inactive for a decade, began operations last year (TT, Oct. 14, 2005), 15 train-related car accidents have occurred, according to La Nación.

 

Facebook Comments

You may be interested

The Tico Times Weekly Digest: Oct. 15, 2018
Tico Times Weekly Digest
785 views
Tico Times Weekly Digest
785 views

The Tico Times Weekly Digest: Oct. 15, 2018

The Tico Times - October 15, 2018

In this week's episode of the Weekly Digest, a wrap-up of last week's heavy rains, plus more news from around…

Guatemala Fuego eruption is over: officials
Guatemala
850 views
Guatemala
850 views

Guatemala Fuego eruption is over: officials

AFP - October 15, 2018

The most recent eruption of Guatemala's Fuego volcano ended Saturday, an official source said, with locals escaping a repeat of June's…

October in Costa Rica: when the Caribbean comes a’callin’
Pic of the Day
1278 views
Pic of the Day
1278 views

October in Costa Rica: when the Caribbean comes a’callin’

The Tico Times - October 15, 2018

Costa Rica's Caribbean coast is famously exempt from many of the typical weather patterns in the rest of the country.…